Skip to content

Best Anchovies To Buy 2023

    Best Anchovies

    Anchovies Buying Guide & Reviews

    Anchovies are becoming more and more popular these days. With the food industry constantly expanding, more and more recipes are coming on the surface that contains this product as one of its ingredients. They have a distinctive taste and are not popular among everyone, but they offer a boost in flavor to anything you put them on. They come in various forms and packaging, making it hard to find the right one for you. To help you with your search, we compared brands, product quality and user ratings to present you with a review of the 10 best anchovies currently available on the market.

    1. Agostino, Anchovies In Oil Jar


    AGOSTINO Anchovies In Jar, 3.35 OZ

      The first product on our list is also a favorite among the crowd. It features a small jar that weighs 3.35 ounces and is perfect for the ones who occasionally like to eat this type of food. It is promised to not contain any hydrogenated fats, high fructose corn syrups, bleached or bromated flour.

      The brand has been on the market for quite some time without letting its customers down in terms of quality and taste. With so many great ratings on Amazon and huge popularity, it is more than good enough to be listed in our review of the 10 best anchovies.

      2. AgostinoRecca Premium Can


      Agostino Recca - Flat Fillets of Anchovies in Olive Oil, (3)- 2 Ounce. Tins

        Another product from the brand AgostinoRecca takes a place on our list. This time it comes in more traditional packaging, making it much more portable and easier to store away. The anchovies in it are of the highest quality and provide you with a great flavor, either eating them alone or adding them to your dishes as an ingredient.

        Because of the brand’s great reputation and versatility, we thought it would be a good idea to mention more than just 1 of their products in our review of the best anchovies.

        3. Reese Rolled Anchovies

        OUR RATING:

        Reese Rolled Anchovies, 2 Ounce Tins (Pack of 10)

          The next product on our list is also one of the most popular and frequently bought ones. It features a package of 10 tins that each weigh 2 ounces. These rolled fillets of anchovies are packed with olive oil and capers, giving your dish a great tangy flavor. The brand is also known to focus more on quality than quantity, which explains its overall popularity on the market.

          Because of its great overall rating on Amazon, a lot of positive feedback from its customers and the number of products sold, it is more than good enough to take a place in our list of the best anchovies.

          4. MW Polar Flat Anchovies In Olive Oil

          OUR RATING:

          MW Polar Flat Anchovies In Olive Oil, 2 Oz (Pack of 18)

            This pack of 18 anchovy fillets is stored in olive oil and is available for a fairly low price. Each can weighs 2 ounces and its contents are carefully prepared before meeting the requirements to be brought to the market. Each fillet is thoroughly cleaned, trimmed of skin and bones removed to ensure the best-tasting experience.

            Not only do you get a huge quantity for a fairly low price, but also great quality, making this a great pick for anyone who wants to try out this type of food in their next dish.

            5. Ortiz Anchovy Fillets in Oil

            OUR RATING:

            Ortiz Anchovy Fillets in Oil 95 Gram Jar

              This 4-ounce jar of anchovies packed in oil is a simple, fairly cheap and high-quality product that many adore. Not only is it possible to purchase only one jar, but it also promises to deliver a great flavor. If you aren’t sure if this type of product/ingredient is what you are looking for, then this might be the safest pick of them all, since it is available for a fairly low price and it comes in low quantities.

              Because of the overall great rating this product has and people claiming it is a great addition to many dishes, we thought it is fair to mention it in our review of the best anchovies currently available.

              6. Rustichella D’ Abruzzo Anchovy Filets

              OUR RATING:

              Rustichella D' Abruzzo Anchovy Filets in Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 3.2 Ounce

                This 3.2-ounce jar of anchovy fillets comes in extra virgin oil and is promised to be of the highest quality. They gently wash it in fresh water and manually debone it to ensure the best outcome in terms of product quality. It goes best on pizza, panini, crostini and when making pasta sauce.

                All in all, it has gained a lot of popularity over time and many products have been sold up until now, making it fit to be listed in our review of the best anchovies.

                7. Cento Flat Anchovies in Olive Oil

                OUR RATING:

                Cento Flat Anchovies in Olive Oil, 2 Ounce

                  The next product in our review weighs 2 ounces and contains flat anchovy fillets stored in olive oil with added salt. It is fairly easy to open and is perfect for trying out this type of product in your dishes for the first time.

                  With a great average rating and a lot of positive feedback from its customers, it is more than good enough to take a place in our top 10 list.

                  8. Crown Prince Flat Anchovies in Olive Oil

                  OUR RATING:

                  Crown Prince Flat Anchovies in Olive Oil, 2-Ounce Cans (Pack of 12)

                    Out of all the mentioned products in our review of the best anchovies, this one has one of the best ratings and most sold items. It features a case of 12 cans that each weigh 2 ounces. They can be easily opened due to their pull-top lids and don’t contain any GMOs. It is also said to be certified Paleo and Keto.

                    The brand has a great reputation on the market and has always tried its best to provide its customers quality over quantity, making it a great addition to our review.

                    9. Wild Planet, Anchovies Wild In Olive Oil

                    OUR RATING:

                    Wild Planet, Anchovies Wild In Olive Oil, 4.37 Ounce

                      If you are looking for anchovies that provide your dishes with a milder flavor, then this might be the right product for you. The package weighs 4.37 ounces and provides you with a basic, but not too strong flavor when added to your dishes.

                      Up until now, it has gained a lot of popularity and has a great overall rating, making it more than good enough to be called one of the best anchovies currently available.

                      10. Bellino Garlic and Parsley Anchovies

                      OUR RATING:

                      Bellino Garlic and Parsley Anchovies, 4.2 Ounce Jar

                        The last item on our list of the best anchovies has some unique ingredients in it. It consists of anchovy fillets, salt, olive oil, garlic and parsley, making them a popular pick among many people. It is said to be the best anchovies for caesar salad dressings and pizzas in terms of taste.

                        It has a lot of positive feedback from its customers and many great overall ratings, giving it just enough good features to make it to our top 10 list.

                        FAQ – Anchovies Frequently Asked Questions

                        Below you can find the most searched questions about anchovies on the internet. We try our best to answer them in as much detail as possible. Hopefully, you will learn something new and it will be easier for you to decide whether you want to buy anchovies.

                        What Is Anchovy?

                        Best Anchovies To Buy 2023 Buying Guide

                        Anchovies are small sea fish that are used as food or as fish bait for larger prey. They come from the family of Engraulidae. You can find them in the Atlantic, Indian and Pacific oceans. Anchovy is a small green fish that classifies as an oily fish. When fully grown, they’ll reach sizes up to 40 centimeters (16 inches) but the anchovies used for food as much smaller, from 2 to 10 centimeters. Usually, they are used in small amounts as a side dish. Because they have a strong flavor, cooks all over the world use them also in sauces.

                        What Is Anchovy Paste?

                        Anchovy paste is made from fermented anchovies, vinegar, spices and water. It’s used as a condiment in many dishes. People are using the paste for centuries and mostly you can find it in the cuisine of Britain, Italy, Vietnam and the Philippines.

                        How To Make Anchovy Paste?

                        To make anchovy paste you’ll need:

                        • 8.8 ounces of drained anchovies
                        • 5.3 ounces of cubed soft butter
                        • 0.3 ounces of fresh white bread crumbs
                        • 1.25 milligrams of cayenne pepper
                        • Pinch of cinnamon
                        • Pinch of ground nutmeg
                        • Pinch of ginger powder
                        • Pinch of ground black pepper

                        Take the anchovies and butter and blend them until smooth using a blender. Add the remaining ingredients. Mix well, so the flavors combine well and then transfer the paste to an airtight container. Refrigerate the paste for 10 minutes before serving.

                        How Long Does Anchovy Paste Last?

                        Because anchovies are fermented when prepared, the paste should last you for around 18 months if the airtight container isn’t open. On the other hand, for opened jars, the expiration date will tell you for how long it’s good. Make sure you refrigerate the past as soon as you open it. If you notice a change in taste or a weaker flavor, it is time you replace the anchovy paste.

                        1 Teaspoon Anchovy Paste Is Equal To How Many Anchovies?

                        Two anchovies are equal to 1 teaspoon of anchovy paste.

                        How Much Anchovy Paste Equals 1 Anchovy?

                        One anchovy is equal to 1/2 teaspoon of anchovy paste.

                        How To Make Anchovy Broth?

                        To make anchovy broth you’ll need:

                        • 1 cup dried anchovies
                        • 1 small sheet of kelp
                        • 10 cups water

                        For 2 hours, let the anchovies and kelp soak. Add to heat and bring it to a boil. Let it boil for 2 minutes more and remove from heat. Remove the anchovies and kelp from the broth. It is suggested you use the broth immediately. If not, you can store it in a refrigerator or freezer.

                        Rating The Best Anchovies Currently Available On The Market

                        Anchovies come in many different forms and packaging, but which are considered the best on the market?

                        In this video of America’s Test Kitchen, you will be shown a few products (some of which are mentioned in our review) and a detailed evaluation of the texture and flavor that it provides. It has made a lot of people’s search easier since it helped them find their favorite brand of anchovies fairly quickly.


                        If you are looking for the best anchovies for pizza, sauces or salad dressings, it is important to always purchase a product that suits your taste. We hope this review was helpful in your search. If you want to learn more about the topic, you are welcome to browse our webpage for more information.