Skip to content

Best Toffee To Buy 2023

    Best Toffee
    Image by: Stratford490

    Toffee Buying Guide & Reviews

    When the need kicks in to eat something sweet, why not try something with a more distinctive flavor like toffee? Its taste and flavor have made it one of the most consumed treats in these modern times. It comes in many different forms and sizes. Many brands offer this product, but not all deliver good quality, making it hard to find the right product for you. To make your search easier, we compared brands, product quality and user ratings to present you a review of the 10 best toffee products you can buy currently on the market.

    1. Walkers Nonsuch English Creamy Toffees


    Walkers Nonsuch English Creamy Toffees, 5.3 oz., Two bags

    The first product on our list is also a favorite among many people. It features 2 packs of creamy toffee with each weighing 5.3 ounces. Its creamy consistency and flavor have brought it to the attention of the public and made it good enough to be mentioned in our top 10 list.

    Not only does it have great ratings on Amazon, but also excellent customer reviews, making it more than good enough to be listed in our review of the best toffee.

    2. Wickedly Prime Roasted Cashews Toffee


    Amazon Brand - Wickedly Prime Roasted Cashews, Coconut Toffee, 8 Ounce

      If you like the sound of cashews, coconut and toffee flavor all in one product, then this might be the perfect choice for you. This 8-ounce resealable bag has been on the market for quite some time without lowering its great average rating. The brand is also confident in its product enough to offer a full refund if not satisfied with it for any reason.

      Because of the brand’s great reputation, great taste that its product offers and huge popularity on the market, it has been sold out a few times now, making it a desired food product and a great addition to our list of the best toffee to buy.

      3. Almond Toffee Petites


      Almond Toffee Petites

      Out of all the mentioned products in this review, this one has by far the best ratings. The whole package contains 75 individually wrapped almond toffees that, by customer reports, deliver a great taste.

      Because of the high average rating and many satisfied customers, it is a must to mention it in our review of the best toffee products currently available on the market.

      4. Toffee Bits Coarse Grinded


      Toffee Bits Coarse Grinded 1 Pound Bulk Bag-FRESH

        If you are looking for a great topping to go with your ice cream, then this would be a great pick. This coarse ground toffee comes in a heat-sealed bag for maximum freshness and offers a true toffee taste. It is promised to be gluten-free and can be used in combination with almost any recipe that uses coarse ground ingredients.

        Since it has great average ratings on Amazon and a lot of positive customer feedback, we decided it would make a great addition to our review of the best toffee to buy.

        5. Walkers Liquorice Toffee

        OUR RATING:

        Walkers Liquorice Toffee 1.25kg Jar

          The next product contains the true British flavor of toffee. The jar it comes in weighs 1.25 kilograms and consists of individually wrapped toffee candy. One of the features that stands out is that it comes in a very fresh form, making them much more enjoyable than many of its competitors.

          People claim that this product didn’t disappoint them in any way. The taste and good quality have made it a popular pick among many and more than good enough to be listed in our review of the best toffee to buy.

          6. Walkers Treacle Toffee

          OUR RATING:

          Walkers Treacle Toffee, 3.5-Ounce Packages (Pack of 10)

            Another product from the brand Walkers takes a place on our top 10 list, which just additionally shows how much effort the brand puts in delivering its customers great quality. This time featuring 35 ounces of toffee, with each candy individually wrapped to keep it fresh at all times. It is made using the traditional English recipe and doesn’t contain any artificial colors or preservatives.

            Because of the brand’s great reputation on the market and overall high ratings on Amazon, it is a great addition to our list of the best toffee currently available.

            7. P-Nuttles Butter Toffee Covered Peanuts

            OUR RATING:

            P-Nuttles Butter Toffee Covered Peanuts, Toffee Peanuts, 44 Ounce Jar Made in the USA, Kosher, Peanuts Sweet, Party Snack, Nuts Gift, Peanuts Bulk,...

              The next product on our list features a 44-ounce container filled with butter toffee-covered peanuts. The brand has been on the market for quite some time and hasn’t let its customers down since the beginning. It makes for a great snack and delivers a great taste. It can easily be resealed using its plastic cover, keeping the contents fresh for a long time.

              Because of all the great feedback from its customers and overall great rating on Amazon, it is considered to be one of the best toffee peanuts currently available on the market.

              8. Butter Toffee Almonds

              OUR RATING:

              Butter Toffee Almonds Fresh Gourmet Sweet and Salty Crunch Resealable Bag from Sohnrey Family Foods (1 lb)

                If you are looking for almonds covered in toffee, then this might be the perfect pick for you! The whole package weighs 1 pound and can easily be resealed to keep its contents fresh for a long time. It is made from simple ingredients, but still delivers the taste many people are looking for. It is said to be a great choice for parties and for when you expect guests.

                All in all, it has been purchased numerous times without lowering its great rating on Amazon, making it a must to mention it in our review of the best toffee products.

                9. Fisher Snack Peanuts, Butter Toffee

                OUR RATING:

                Fisher Snack Butter Toffee Peanuts, 5.5 Ounces (Pack of 6), No Artificial Colors or Flavors

                  This product features 6 resealable pouches, with each containing 5.5 ounces of butter toffee peanuts. It doesn’t contain any artificial colors or flavors, making it very popular among a lot of people. Its rich flavor and quality have skyrocketed it to the top of the market.

                  Because it has a lot of great customer feedback and a great rating on Amazon, it has deserved the title of one of the best toffee peanut products currently available.

                  10. Hershey’s Nuggets Toffee

                  OUR RATING:

                  Hershey's Nuggets Milk Chocolate w/ Toffee and Almonds (Pack of 2)

                    If you are looking for a treat made out of milk chocolate, toffee and almonds, then look no further, because this product is one of the best. It is said to contain no gluten and that it is Kosher. The whole package contains 2 of these nugget packs.

                    Since it offers an interesting and delicious product made in combination with toffee, we thought it would make a great addition to our top 10 list.

                    FAQ – Toffee Frequently Asked Questions

                    Below you can find the most searched questions about toffee on the internet. We try our best to answer them in as much detail as possible. Hopefully, you will learn something new and it will be easier for you to decide whether you want to buy toffee.

                    What Is Toffee?


                    Toffee is a confection made from caramelized sugar with butter. It is less sweet than most sweets because it is made half from butter. There are many variations on how to prepare toffee. For example, people even include nuts and raisins in their recipes. The process for making toffee is easy, the mixture of sugar and butter needs to be heated up to 150°C(300°F) that then gives it a hard consistency it’s known as.

                    How To Make Homemade Toffee Candy?

                    To make delicious homemade toffee candy you’ll need:

                    8 oz. unsalted butter
                    1 c. granulated sugar
                    2 tbsp. water
                    1 tsp. salt
                    1 tsp. vanilla extract
                    1 c. chocolate chips
                    3 tbsp. pecans or almonds

                    1. Take a baking sheet and butter it or line it with parchment paper. Take a medium-sized saucepan and add sugar, water, salt and butter to it.
                    2. Put the saucepan on the stove and set the heat to medium and with the help of a wooden spoon, keep stirring until the butter melts and sugar dissolves. If you would like, you can attach a candy thermometer at this point.
                    3. Keep cooking it over medium heat until the thermometer has reached 285°F(140°C) or the mixture got a nice caramel color to it. Remove from heat and add the vanilla extract.
                    4. Pour onto the baking sheet you’ve prepared earlier and spread it. Before sprinkling it with chocolate chips, let it rest for 5 minutes. Let it cool for 10 minutes more.
                    5. With the help of an offset spatula, spread the chocolate chips and sprinkle chopped almonds or pecans on top.
                    6. Let cool completely and then break into desired shaped pieces.

                    What Is English Toffee And How To Make It?

                    English toffee is a variation that was invented in the United States, where it’s very popular to this day. It’s very buttery and usually, it’s made with almonds in hard and chewy forms.

                    To make Homemade English toffee you’ll need:

                    1 c. real butter
                    1 c. sugar
                    1/4 c. water
                    1/2 tsp. salt
                    1/2 c. chocolate chips
                    1 c. crushed pecans

                    1. Take a heavy saucepan and add butter, sugar, water, and salt to it.
                    2. Put it on the stove over medium heat and stir constantly with a wooden spoon until it reaches 300°F(150°C) on the candy thermometer.
                    3. Remove from stove and pour into an ungreased pan.
                    4. Let it cool until it’s got a hard consistency to it.
                    5. Heat the water and don’t let it boil: add the chocolate chips.
                    6. Spread the melted chocolate over the now hardened toffee and sprinkle the crushed pecans on top.
                    7. Set aside and let it cool for 2 hours.
                    8. Break into desired shapes and enjoy!

                    What Is Butter Toffee And How To Make It?

                    Butter toffee is a hard candy made from sugar and butter. It’s eaten alone or added as a topping to desserts.

                    To make homemade butter toffee you’ll need:
                    – 3 c. chopped almonds
                    – 12 oz. chocolate chips
                    – 2 1/3 c. sugar
                    – 2 c. unsalted butter
                    – 6 tbsp. water
                    – 2 tsp. corn syrup

                    1. Preheat your oven to 350°F(175°C).
                    2. Take a baking sheet and add the chopped almonds and toast them for 7 minutes, stirring for the last 3 minutes.
                    3. Discard the almonds into a bowl and set them aside.
                    4. Take two baking sheets and line them with parchment paper.
                    5. Take a large pot and add sugar, butter, water and corn syrup to it. Put it on the stove over medium hit and stir constantly.
                    6. Attach a candy thermometer and cook for 25 minutes more or until the thermometer reaches 300°F(150°C), stirring every 3 minutes.
                    7. Stir in the chopped and toasted almonds.
                    8. Spread the mixture evenly in each pan.
                    9. Sprinkle chocolate chips on top.
                    10. Let the chocolate chips sit on top for 5 minutes and then with the help of an offset spatula, spread evenly.
                    11. Let it cool for 4 hours before eating.

                    How To Make Toffee Sauce?

                    To make toffee sauce you’ll need:

                    1 c. heavy cream
                    1 c. brown sugar
                    1/2 c. real unsalted butter
                    pinch of salt
                    1 tsp. vanilla extract

                    1. Take a medium-sized saucepan and add the heavy cream, brown sugar salt and butter. Put it on the stove over medium heat.
                    2. While stirring constantly, cook until the brown sugar completely dissolves. 3. Once dissolved, increase the heat to medium-high and stir until the mixture gets a dark amber color to it.
                    4. Remove the toffee mixture from heat and stir in the vanilla extract. If the mixture is too thick, keep adding butter and reheat until you reach the desired consistency.

                    How To Make Toffee Popcorn?

                    To make delicious homemade toffee popcorn you’ll need:

                    1 tablespoon sunflower oil
                    3 ounces popcorn
                    1.7 ounce salted butter
                    3.5 ounces brown sugar
                    2 tablespoons golden syrup

                    1. Take a large saucepan and heat the sunflower oil. Add the corn and mix so the corn gets evenly coated in the oil. cover with a lid and set the heat to low while shaking the pan consistently until the popping stops.
                    2. Take a medium-sized pan and add the butter, sugar and syrup. Add to heat and cook until the butter melts. Gradually increase the heat and let it bubble for 2 minutes. Pour over your already made popcorn and stir well to combine.
                    3. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and add the popcorn. Let cool for 15 minutes and enjoy!

                    What Color Is Toffee And What Does It Taste Like?

                    Toffee is golden colored and has a sweet and buttery flavor and because chocolate is added it is a super tasty dessert. You can prepare it in hard or chewy form and you can eat it alone or add it to desserts and snacks.

                    What Is The Difference Between Toffee And Caramel?

                    Toffee and caramel almost look the same. They’re both candies made mainly from sugar that can be used in combination with many desserts. The difference is in the texture and taste. Toffee is hard and crunchy, while the caramel is soft and chewy. Also, toffee tastes much more buttery than caramel.

                    Making Toffee Candy At Home

                    Sam from Sugar Spun Run teaches you how to make delicious toffee candy at home. Make sure to check out the description of the video, because you got time stamps listed there and the full recipe.


                    With so many different products currently available on the market, it can be hard to find the right one for you. We hope this review was helpful in your search. If you want to learn more about this topic, you are always welcome to browse our website for more information.