Skip to content

10 Best Tartar Sauce Brands 2022

    Best Tartar Sauce Brands - Buying Guide
    Image by: jeffreyw

    When preparing a seafood dish or simply wanting to dip your veggies in something for a boost in taste, one of the most popular sauces is the tartar sauce. It comes in various packaging, with various ingredients that offer unique tastes. It is always important to purchase a product of good quality to ensure that your meal can be enjoyed to its fullest. With so many brands currently offering this product, it can be hard to find the right one for you. To make your search easier, we compared brands, product quality and user ratings to present you with a review of the 10 best tartar sauce brands currently available on the market.

    1. McCormick Golden Dipt Tartar Sauce


    McCormick Golden Dipt Tartar Sauce, 8 fl oz

      In terms of quality and popularity, this brand beats most of its competition. It has been on the market for quite some time with all kinds of products. Their tartar sauce hasn’t let its customers down in any way as well. Its unique flavor makes it a great addition to any seafood or simply used as a dip for anything you might think of. It gained so much popularity that restaurants even started serving it to their customers.

      Many people claim this to be the best tartar sauce brand currently on the market. Not only because of its huge popularity, but also its taste. All in all, a great 1st pick for our top 10 list.

      2. Heinz Single Serve Tartar Sauce


      Heinz Single Serve Tartar Sauce (200 ct Casepack)

        When talking about sauces, Heinz is a brand you simply have to mention. Their tartar sauce is no exception. It is said to be one of the best options for seafood dishes, fries or making burgers and sandwiches. They have been in the business for a long time now and are trying to offer their customers great quality for a fairly low price, which in many people’s opinions, they have succeeded.

        Because of the brand’s great reputation worldwide and their tartar sauce being of the highest quality and offering a great dip or sauce for almost any food, it is counted among one of the best tartar sauce brands currently available on the market.

        3. Louisiana Tartar Home Style Sauce

        OUR RATING:

        Louisiana Tartar Home Style Sauce, 10.5 oz

          A typical tartar sauce brand that has its origins in the USA. If you are looking for a great American product that will leave your taste buds satisfied, then look no further! Not only is it packaged in a handy container that makes it easy to store away, but it also promises to deliver a great taste when eaten with seafood. It’s secret? A great combination of soybean oil, chopped pickles and a vast amount of spices and herbs.

          Among many products, this one has one of the best ratings on Amazon. If we count in all of the positive feedback from its customers, it is more than fit to take a place on our list of the best tartar sauce brands.

          4. Frischs Sauce Tartar Original

          OUR RATING:

          Frischs Sauce Tartar Original

            If you are looking for a larger quantity of tartar sauce to serve at any family dinner, picnic or any event in general where many people are attending, the next product would be a great pick for that. Not only does the brand have a good reputation on the market, but it also uses only high-quality ingredients for its product to ensure a great taste. The handy design also makes it easy to keep fresh and to store it away when not needed anymore.

            With exceptional ratings on Amazon and great customer feedback, it is more than good enough to be called one of the best tartar sauce brands currently on the market.

            5. Bookbinders Sauce Tartar

            OUR RATING:

            Bookbinders Sauce Tartar, 9.5 Ounce (Pack of 2)

            The next product gained its popularity not only because of the brand’s reputation but also of its unique recipe. It is a great addition to any seafood in general with people claiming it to be the best tartar sauce for making fish sandwiches. It gives a great taste to it without overpowering all of the flavors. So if you are looking for a product for making sandwiches, then this might be a good choice!

            With many great ratings and great customer feedback on Amazon, it is considered to be one of the best tartar sauce brands currently available on the market.

            6. Stonewall Kitchen Down East Tartar Sauce

            OUR RATING:

            Stonewall Kitchen Down East Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Ounces

              The next brand is well known among many people for many of its products. They offer a vast variety of products for cooking, baking and much more. Their tartar sauce is just one out of several products that have huge popularity among many people. It is especially well-liked when used in combination with seafood, deviled eggs and tuna salads.

              Not only does it come for a fairly low price, but it also promises to add a great flavor to your meals. With so much great customer feedback and overall great ratings, it is more than good enough to be called one of the best tartar sauce brands.

              7. Kraft Tartar Sauce

              OUR RATING:

              Kraft Tartar Sauce, 12 Fl Oz

                The next product has one of the most ratings on Amazon among all of the mentioned products in our top 10 review. Not only quantity but also quality is a key factor when it comes to Kraft’s tartar sauce because people claim it to be a great addition to many meals, great for snacks or used for dips. Its handy container makes it easy to store away and keeps its contents fresh for a long time. Its unique recipe is promised to be Kosher and offers a great taste when used in combination with your favorite seafood.

                If you don’t like to take risks when purchasing sauces over the internet, then this might be a safe pick in terms of flavor and user feedback. With so many positive features, how can we not mention it in our review of the best tartar sauce brands?

                8. Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce

                OUR RATING:

                Primal Kitchen Tartar Sauce, 7.5 Oz

                  If you want to try something with a more modern approach in terms of design and ingredients, then this might be the right pick for you! It features several ingredients that are unique for tartar sauces without sacrificing flavor and great taste in the process. It is also promised to be gluten-free and to create a smooth and delicious flavor when eaten with your favorite dishes.

                  Since it is one of few brands that use avocado oil in their products, we decided to add this product to our list. And don’t worry, its customer’s feedback is also very positive!

                  9. Woeber Sauce Tartar

                  OUR RATING:

                  Woeber Sauce Tartar Supreme Sweet Tangy, 10 oz

                    The next product promises to use only high-quality certified Kosher ingredients, of which the highlighted ones are mustard seeds, vinegar and spices. It is said to be one of the best tartar sauce brands for dips or sandwich spreads. The handy container makes it very easy to store it away and the fairly low price makes it more than affordable for almost anyone.

                    Up until now, it has gotten quite a lot of popularity on the market. It has given a lot of attention to maximizing quality over quantity, which made it viable to be listed in our review of the 10 best tartar sauce brands.

                    10. Beaver Brand Gourmet Tatar Sauce

                    The next brand has been producing specialty condiments since 1929. Throughout the years they have perfected their recipes and eventually also made a tartar sauce. It is very popular when being used in combination with almost any seafood dish, but can also be used for dips and much more. The handy squeeze bottle provides you with practicality and an easy storing method.

                    All in all, it has gotten huge popularity among the crowd and a great overall rating on Amazon, making it fit to take the last place on our list of the 10 best tartar sauce brands.

                    FAQ – Tartar Sauce Frequently Asked Questions

                    Below you can find the most searched questions about tartar sauce on the internet. We try our best to answer them in as much detail as possible. Hopefully, you will learn something new and it will be easier for you to decide whether you want to buy tartar sauce.

                    What Is Tartar Sauce?

                    Tartar sauce is a condiment often served with seafood, but goes well too with french fries. Tartar sauce got its name in 1921 when it got associated with the raw meat dish called Steak Tartare.

                    What Is Tartar Sauce Made Of?

                    Tartar sauce is made with mayonnaise, pickles, capers, lemon juice and dill. You got a lot of varieties, some include olives, apple cider, onions, shallots and more.

                    How To Make Homemade Tartar Sauce?

                    You will need:

                    • 1 cup of real mayonnaise
                    • 1 cup of finely chopped dill pickles
                    • 1 tablespoon of chopped fresh parsley
                    • 1 teaspoon of lemon juice, 1 teaspoon of sugar,
                    • 1/4 teaspoon of ground black pepper
                    • optionally you can add and 2 tablespoons of chopped onions.

                    The process is probably one of the easiest recipes of all time:

                    • Simply combine all the ingredients above in a bowl, stir well and you’re done. If the flavor is too weak for you, add lemon juice or more dill pickles.

                    How Many Carbs, Fat and Calories Are In Tartar Sauce?

                    In 1 serving size (28 grams) there are 2 grams of carbs, 10 grams of fat and 130 milligrams of sodium, resulting in 100 calories.

                    What Does Tartar Sauce Taste Like?

                    Tartar sauce tastes like mayonnaise with pickle relish and a twang.

                    How Long Does Tartar Sauce Last?

                    Tartar sauce will last you for up to 6 months, refrigerated. If you notice a change in texture or flavor, it is time to replace it.


                    If you are a seafood lover you know how important it is to find a tartar sauce that offers a great flavor but doesn’t take away the spark from your main dish. We hope this review was helpful in your search. If you want to learn more about the topic, you are welcome to browse our webpage for more information.